Part 2: What is an Option Clause in a Commercial Lease?

In Short

• Clearly define tenant default conditions in the option clause to prevent disputes and protect both parties’ interests.
• Specify the new lease terms – duration, rent, and rent review method—to avoid ambiguity and ensure a smooth renewal process.
• Retail leases must comply with state-specific legislation on rent reviews and tenant notification requirements.

Tips for Businesses

When renewing a commercial or retail lease, review the option clause carefully. Ensure it clearly covers default conditions, new lease terms, and rent review methods. For retail leases, confirm that the landlord has met all notification obligations under state tenancy laws before exercising your renewal option.

Summarise with: ChatGPT Perplexity Microsoft Copilot

---

Table of Contents

• Consequences of Tenant Default
• Specifying the New Lease Terms
• Rent Review Methods
• Retail Leases
• Key Takeaways
• Frequently Asked Questions

When drafting an option clause in a commercial lease, it is critical to understand how tenant default, new lease terms, and rent reviews are addressed. These components ensure clarity, protect both parties’ interests, and prevent disputes down the line. This article expands on the key considerations highlighted in the previous article.

How to End a Lease Factsheet

A factsheet that sets out the three ways to end a commercial lease in Australia: surrendering your lease, assigning it or subletting it.

Download Now

Consequences of Tenant Default

It is common practice for option clauses to be conditional upon the tenant not breaching the lease agreement. This provision protects landlords from renewing leases with tenants who have shown non-compliance or unreliable behaviour during the tenancy. Including an explicit default provision in the lease ensures both parties are aware of their obligations and consequences.

The key to an effective default clause is precision. A clause that prevents renewal for any breach may create uncertainty or lead to disputes over what constitutes a breach. Include a clear threshold defining significant or repeated breaches that would trigger loss of the renewal option. For example, a clause could state that a tenant cannot renew if they miss rent payments more than twice during the lease. It may also prevent renewal if the tenant breaches material provisions of the agreement multiple times.

Additionally, the timing of a breach is essential. Some leases require tenants not to be in breach when exercising the option. Others also require compliance at the lease’s expiry date. Such provisions offer landlords greater protection, ensuring that the tenant remains compliant throughout the tenancy.

Specifying the New Lease Terms

An option clause must clearly outline the terms that will apply to the renewed lease. This includes the duration of the new lease, the rent payable, and the mechanism for rent review. Without these details, ambiguity could arise, leading to potential disputes between the parties about the new terms.

A well-drafted option clause should provide a seamless transition from the old lease to the new one. A vague clause or one leaving matters for later agreement can create uncertainty and potential disputes. For example, without clear rent terms, tenants may expect lower amounts than landlords, which can create tension during negotiations. Additionally, while the option clause can reference existing terms from the original lease, it is vital to ensure any new terms or amendments are mutually agreed upon and reflected in a formal Deed of Renewal.

Rent Review Methods

Rent review mechanisms are another essential part of the option clause. For commercial leases, standard methods include fixed percentage increases or market rent reviews. Retail leases, however, are subject to more stringent regulations.

Retail Leases

Under the retail legislation in all states of Australia, the market rent review is outlined in the Acts, including the option for an early market rent review. This right ensures that tenants can assess whether the new rent is reasonable before committing to the renewal term with the new rental amount.

For landlords in retail leasing, failure to notify the tenant of the new rent prior to the option exercise date can have significant consequences. In some states, the option period may be extended until the rent is determined. This legislative protection for retail leases helps ensure tenants are fully informed and can make an educated decision about whether to renew their lease.

Retail leases often involve additional considerations compared to standard commercial leases, primarily due to the protective nature of retail tenancy laws. In Australia, retail leases are subject to state-specific legislation designed to protect the rights of retail tenants. This can include additional requirements around rent reviews, option periods, and termination rights. For example, failure to conduct a market rent review in accordance with the lease can result in the option being extended, giving the tenant more time to decide based on accurate rental figures.

Key Takeaways

An option clause can provide security for both landlords and tenants, but only if it is properly negotiated and drafted. Careful consideration of tenant default provisions, lease terms, and rent review mechanisms ensures that both parties are clear on their rights and obligations. In retail leases, compliance with the specific legislative requirements is equally important to avoid any unintended consequences. Given the complexities involved, it is always advisable to seek expert legal advice when negotiating or drafting these clauses. 

If you need assistance with option clauses or other leasing matters, our experienced leasing lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page.

Frequently Asked Questions