6 FAQs about a Notice to Show Cause

In Short

• Notice to Show Cause: A formal notice requiring an individual or business to explain or justify their actions to avoid a particular consequence, such as termination, disciplinary action or legal penalties.
• Purpose: Ensures procedural fairness by giving the recipient an opportunity to respond before a decision is made.
• Legal Requirements: Must clearly state the allegations, specify a response timeframe, and outline the potential consequences of failing to respond.

Tips for Businesses

If your business receives a notice to show cause, act promptly and review the notice carefully. Gather all relevant information and evidence, respond clearly within the timeframe, and consult a lawyer to ensure your response protects your business interests and complies with legal obligations.

Summarise with: ChatGPT Perplexity Microsoft Copilot

---

Table of Contents

• 1. What is a Notice to Show Cause?
• 2. When is a Notice to Show Cause Used?
• 3. Are There Different Forms of a Notice to Show Cause? 
• 4. What Types of Show Cause Notices Are There?
• 5. What Are the Consequences of Failing to Respond to a Notice to Show Cause Adequately?
• 6. How Do I Respond to a Notice to Show Cause?
• Key Takeaways
• Frequently Asked Questions

Receiving a formal legal document can be alarming, and a notice to show cause is no exception. Understanding these notices is crucial, as they can lead to further legal proceedings. Responding promptly and thoroughly is vital to avoid adverse consequences. We will cover what a notice to show cause is, when it is used, the different forms it can take, and the consequences of failing to respond adequately. This knowledge is essential for navigating potential legal challenges effectively. This article will address six frequently asked questions to help you comprehend the implications and necessary actions if you receive such a notice.

1. What is a Notice to Show Cause?

A notice to show cause is a formal document issued to one party in a dispute. It sets out details of an alleged offence or misconduct. In doing so, the receiving party will have the chance to explain themselves or otherwise face some further consequences. Therefore, it is important to respond promptly and thoroughly to a show cause notice. You should also understand the implications of failing to respond adequately. 

2. When is a Notice to Show Cause Used?

A notice to show cause may be used in a wide variety of situations, from court case proceedings to workplace disciplinary proceedings. These situations may occur from a range of wrongdoings, such as a contractual breach, violation of rules and regulations, or an offence that requires an explanation. A notice allows the receiving party to tell their side of the story and explain why further action should not be taken. In other words, it ensures any proceedings between the receiving and sending parties are fair and just.

3. Are There Different Forms of a Notice to Show Cause? 

A notice to show cause has many forms. All types have a similar effect, being some form of disciplinary process. This may be, for instance, a punishment or penalty if you do not reply within the deadline or in an adequate manner. Additionally,  a notice is usually issued to bring a matter to a head and prompt a decisive response. For example, it may be issued by a court to a party for not complying with the court timetable. 

4. What Types of Show Cause Notices Are There?

There are a wide variety of show cause notices that may appear in different aspects of your commercial activities. Common types are set out below.

Court 

A court may issue a show cause order during proceedings. This may require you or the other party to justify, explain or prove something to the court. Common requests include providing more information to the judge, who will consider it before deciding to issue an order requested by one party. 

Employment 

If you are an employee, your employer may issue a show cause notice concerning your conduct or behaviour. It may signal the employer’s intention to take disciplinary action if you do not effectively explain why you acted wrongfully. However, you should note a notice is usually reserved for serious misconduct or matters such as workplace bullying or underperformance.

Consumer Law

Bodies that regulate consumer law, such as NSW Fair Trading, may issue a notice to any business it believes has breached consumer laws. If you were the business owner in this case, the notice gives you the chance to make submissions to explain your conduct and potentially avoid disciplinary action. 

Insolvency

Regulatory bodies like the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Australian Financial Security Authority (AFSA) use notices to investigate and discipline insolvency practitioners. ASIC and AFSA can issue a notice to show cause where they have reason to believe such an individual has breached their duties, such as by:

• committing fraud or misconduct;
• failing to have the correct insurance; or 
• failing to show the required skill and experience of a practitioner. 

Construction

A party to a construction contract may issue a notice to show cause. Generally, this occurs if it believes the other party has breached the contract and, as a result, wishes to terminate the agreement. Without a notice issued, the other party may claim they have been unjustly or unreasonably dismissed by that party, also known as an unfair dismissal claim. 

Local Council

Homeowners or landowners may receive a notice from their local council about a non-complying building or structure on the property. For example, your council may issue a notice relating to a retaining wall or fence it deems hazardous. Another potential reason for a notice would be if you are using the building for a purpose outside any development consent. 

5. What Are the Consequences of Failing to Respond to a Notice to Show Cause Adequately?

Failing to respond to any type of notice to show cause will usually result in some sort of damage or penalty. A failure to respond to your notice to show cause can mean that a decision is made, despite your lack of response. It can result in further legal action, such as a termination of contract or imposition of penalties. Potential adverse consequences ultimately depend on the nature of the dispute. 

6. How Do I Respond to a Notice to Show Cause?

You should take the following steps if you receive a notice:  

1. Note the deadline for response: It will usually be between 14 and 28 days but can be sooner. If you cannot meet the deadline, you should contact the issuing party as soon as possible and request an extension.
2. Check the details: If any facts are not accurate, notify the issuing party as soon as possible. 
3. Get legal advice: You should seek the assistance of a lawyer if the matter is complex or has the potential to do serious damage to your business or professional standing. One example of this is if you are an insolvency practitioner and risk losing your licence.
4. Prepare a response: Check the requirements for responding to the notice and respond as directed. That may require additional documents as evidence or a supporting statement from any witness or other parties. 
5. Challenge the notice: If you are clear that the notice was incorrectly issued or the alleged offence has not occurred, you may wish to challenge the notice. This may be included in any general arguments during a legal proceeding. However, you should read any terms carefully to confirm if a challenge is to take a different form.
6. Give notice of any action taken by you in response: For example, if you have arranged to have a hazardous boundary fence repaired, notify the council to inform it that you have complied with the notice. It may wish to re-inspect the property to confirm the correct action has been taken. 

Guide to Resolving Business Disputes

This guide provides key information on how to manage a business dispute as quickly and cost-effectively as possible.

Download Now

Key Takeaways

Receiving a notice to show cause may be shocking, but importantly, it prompts you about a potentially damaging claim. These notices can arise in many situations that may be relevant to you, including:

• court;
• the course of employment;
• business activities with consumers;
• insolvency practices;
• construction contracts; and
• local council matters.

Furthermore, a notice to show cause provides you with the opportunity to respond and tell your side of the story. If you fail to respond, the resulting penalty may be more damaging. You should take any notice seriously and should respond quickly and thoroughly. Seeking legal advice is crucial to ensure you address the notice effectively and mitigate any adverse consequences.

If you would like assistance regarding a notice to show cause, contact our experienced dispute resolution lawyers as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page. 

Frequently Asked Questions