In Short:
- Unilateral variation allows franchisors to change franchise agreement terms without franchisee consent.
- The Franchising Code of Conduct regulates these changes, requiring good faith and transparency.
- Franchisees can dispute unfair variations and use alternative dispute resolution processes.
Tips for Businesses:
When dealing with unilateral variations, ensure your franchise agreement outlines clear notice and dispute resolution procedures. Be mindful of the potential impact of changes on your operations and financials. Open communication with your franchisor can help mitigate concerns and ensure fair handling of any proposed adjustments, promoting a balanced and sustainable business relationship.
Franchise agreements are integral for Australian franchises, offering a structured and highly regulated framework for franchisor-franchisee relationships. A critical aspect of franchise agreements and relationships is unilateral variation. This article explains what a unilateral variation is and how it could impact you when operating within a franchising network in Australia.
What Is Unilateral Variation?
Unilateral variation refers to one party’s right to modify the terms of an agreement without the explicit consent of the other party. In the context of franchising, this is typically done by the franchisor. This empowers the franchisor to alter certain aspects of the agreement without approval. However, this practice is subject to scrutiny and regulation to ensure a fair and balanced relationship between franchisor and franchisee.
Concerns Associated With Unilateral Variation
Franchise agreements with unilateral variation can raise serious concerns for franchisees. These clauses mean franchisors can impose unilateral variations, potentially harming franchisee interests without proper consultation or justification.
Common unilateral variations include adjustments to:
- royalty fees;
- marketing contributions;
- territory rights; and
- broad operational procedures.
Franchisors may argue that these changes are essential to adapt to evolving markets or maintain franchise competitiveness. However, franchisees typically view them as unfair burdens, especially if they result in:
- increased franchisee operational costs;
- reduced franchisee benefits; and
- limited flexibility.
Regulations for Unilateral Variation
The Franchising Code of Conduct (the Code) governs franchise agreements in Australia. This code obliges franchisors to act in good faith and deal withtheir franchisees fairly. To address concerns of franchisor overreach, the Code provides franchisees with mechanisms to challenge unfair or unreasonable unilateral variations.
Good Faith
While the Code may not explicitly regulate unilateral variations, the concept of good faith is crucial. There is an implied duty of good faith in franchise relationships. Therefore, any unilateral variations must be exercised reasonably and in good faith. The franchisor must also consider the impact on the franchisee’s business.
Notice Requirements
The Code requires franchisors to provide franchisees with written notice of any changes to the agreement at least 14 days before they take effect. This ensures transparency and allows franchisees sufficient time to review the proposed modifications and consult with legal counsel.
Material Changes and Substantial Adverse Effects
Franchisors should proactively assess whether their proposed unilateral changes are material and would cause a substantial negative impact on the franchisee’s business. Franchisees have the right to dispute such variations if they believe they will likely have a significant negative impact.
Alternative Dispute Resolution
The Franchise Code requires alternative dispute resolution for disputes arising from unilateral variations. Franchise agreements should also have built-in dispute resolution mechanisms. These empower franchisees to address concerns. Additionally, they allow them to negotiate with franchisors in a structured and impartial setting.
The ultimate guide to setting up a franchise.
The Importance of Clear Communication and Collaboration
Beyond legal requirements, strong communication channels are vital to managing unilateral variations in franchise networks. Open dialogue between franchisors and franchisees ensures both sides work together on proposed adjustments.
Proactive collaboration also minimises conflict. By involving franchisees, franchisors gain valuable feedback on the impact and feasibility of changes across the network. This transparency fosters a collaborative spirit, focusing on the success and long-term health of the franchise system.
Key Takeaways
Understanding the implications of a unilateral variation in a franchise agreement is crucial for both franchisors and franchisees. These changes can affect the delicate balance between following regulations, good faith conduct and collaborative engagement. Therefore, to build a strong franchise network, franchise agreements and unilateral variations need to be fair, safeguarding both franchisor and franchisee interests. Additionally, both parties should approach the relationship with transparency and good faith. This approach fosters a long-term, mutually beneficial franchise relationship.
If you are considering entering a franchise network or establishing your own franchised business, our experienced franchising lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. You will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents for a low monthly fee. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Unilateral variation refers to a franchisor’s ability to change the terms of the franchise agreement without the franchisee’s explicit consent. These changes could include adjustments to fees, marketing contributions, or operational procedures.
The concept of good faith requires that unilateral variations be made reasonably and fairly, with consideration for the potential impact on the franchisee’s business.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
