Understanding Shareholder Lawsuits
Shareholder lawsuits are legal actions brought by individuals or groups who own shares in a company against the company itself, its directors, or other parties associated with the business. These lawsuits typically arise when shareholders believe their rights or interests have been violated, or when they suspect misconduct or mismanagement within the company.
In Australia, the legal framework governing shareholder rights and corporate conduct is primarily established by the Corporations Act 2001, as well as various other state and federal laws. These laws provide the foundation for shareholder lawsuits and outline the circumstances under which such actions can be pursued.
This Board Reporting Toolkit can help you meet your compliance needs, by explaining your obligations as a director and providing you with a series of tools and templates to ensure you can correctly undertake your key obligations.
Shareholders of the Company
To fully grasp the concept of shareholder lawsuits, it’s essential to understand the role of shareholders within a company. Shareholders are individuals or entities that own shares in a company. By purchasing these shares, they essentially become partial owners of the company, with their ownership stake proportional to the number of shares they hold.
As owners, shareholders have certain rights and expectations regarding the company’s management and performance. These rights typically include voting on major corporate decisions, receiving dividends when declared, and having access to certain financial information about the company. Moreover, shareholders have a vested interest in the company’s success, as the value of their investment is directly tied to the company’s performance and prospects.
When shareholders believe that their rights have been infringed upon or that the company is being mismanaged in a manner that negatively impacts their investment, they may consider taking legal action. This is where shareholder lawsuits come into play, serving as a means for investors to seek redress and protect their interests.
Continue reading this article below the formBreach of Director Duties
One of the most common grounds for shareholder lawsuits is the breach of directors’ duties. In Australia, company directors owe a range of legal duties to the company and, by extension, to its shareholders. These duties are outlined in the Corporations Act 2001 and include:
- the duty to act in good faith in the best interests of the company;
- the duty to exercise care and diligence;
- the duty to avoid conflicts of interest; and
- the duty to prevent insolvent trading.
When directors fail to fulfil these duties, shareholders may have grounds to sue. For instance, if a director makes decisions that clearly benefit themselves at the expense of the company or fails to exercise proper care in making crucial business decisions, shareholders may pursue legal action.
It’s essential to note that directors’ duties are owed primarily to the company itself, rather than to individual shareholders. However, shareholders can bring what’s known as a “derivative action” on behalf of the company against directors who have breached their duties. This allows shareholders to step in and protect the company’s interests when those in charge fail to do so.
Breach of Shareholders’ Rights and Processes under the Corporations Act
The Corporations Act 2001 provides a framework for protecting shareholders’ rights and ensuring proper corporate governance. When companies fail to adhere to these statutory requirements, shareholders may have grounds for legal action.
Some key areas where breaches might occur include:
- failure to hold annual general meetings as required;
- denying shareholders their voting rights;
- not providing shareholders with access to company records or financial statements; and
- failing to disclose material information that could affect share prices.
Shareholder Oppression
Shareholder oppression occurs when the affairs of a company are conducted in a manner that is:
- unfairly prejudicial to; or
- unfairly discriminatory against one or more shareholders.
This is often seen in smaller, closely held companies, where the majority shareholders may use their power to disadvantage minority shareholders.
Examples of oppressive conduct can include:
- excluding minority shareholders from company management;
- withholding dividends without justification;
- diverting company assets or opportunities for personal gain; and
- making important decisions without proper consultation.
In cases of shareholder oppression, affected shareholders can seek relief under Section 232 of the Corporations Act. The court has broad powers to remedy oppressive conduct, including:
- ordering the purchase of shares;
- regulating the company’s affairs; or
- even winding up the company in extreme cases.
Misleading or Deceptive Conduct
Another significant basis for shareholder lawsuits is the company’s or its directors’ conduct that is misleading or deceptive. This can occur in various contexts, but it often involves misrepresentations about the company’s financial position, prospects, or significant events that could impact share value.
The Australian Consumer Law prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce, and this extends to communications with shareholders and the broader market. Common examples include:
- providing false or misleading information in financial reports;
- failing to disclose material information that could affect share prices; and
- making overly optimistic statements about the company’s future prospects without reasonable grounds.
Key Takeaways
In conclusion, shareholder lawsuits serve as an important tool for investors to protect their rights and interests in the companies they partially own. While the grounds for such lawsuits can vary, they generally arise from breaches of legal duties, violations of shareholder rights, oppressive conduct, or misleading behaviour by the company or its directors.
It’s crucial for both shareholders and company directors to be aware of these potential legal issues. Shareholders should stay informed about their rights and the company’s performance, while directors must ensure they’re fulfilling their legal duties and maintaining transparent, fair practices in corporate governance. By doing so, companies can foster trust with their shareholders and potentially avoid costly and reputation-damaging litigation.
If you have any questions, our experienced business lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
When can shareholders sue a company?
Shareholders can sue for breaches of director duties, violations of shareholder rights, oppressive conduct, or misleading information that negatively impacts the company’s value or their investment.
What are director duties under Australian law?
Directors must act in good faith, exercise care and diligence, avoid conflicts of interest, and prevent insolvent trading. Failing to meet these duties can lead to shareholder lawsuits.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
