In Short
-
Legal Protections: The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) safeguards minority shareholders against oppressive or unfair conduct by majority shareholders.
-
Financial Implications: Minority interests can affect financial reporting and tax obligations, potentially leading to increased compliance costs.
-
Governance Strategies: Implementing strong corporate governance and clear communication can help manage relationships with minority shareholders.
Tips for Businesses
To effectively manage minority interests, establish a comprehensive shareholders’ agreement outlining rights and responsibilities. Regularly engage with all shareholders to maintain transparency and trust. Ensure compliance with legal obligations to prevent disputes and protect the company’s integrity.
Minority interests, also known as non-controlling interests, are financial measurements that are used to describe the amount of ownership in a subsidiary company that is not owned by the holding company. A minority interest occurs when the holding company has less than 100% ownership in a subsidiary but more than 50%.
Generally, the minority interest ranges between 20% and 30% of the company’s equity. The minority interest is the remainder of the company which can be owned by one or more shareholders. This article explores the key legal and financial considerations Australian companies must navigate when dealing with minority interests, focusing on compliance requirements, best practices, and potential risks.
Know which key terms to negotiate when buying a business to protect your interests and gain a favourable outcome.
Ownership in the Company
Any shareholder who owns a minority interest does not have complete control over the company’s business decisions, which are left to the shareholders as they are not able to outvote the parent company.
Conversely, this means the holding company does not fully own the subsidiary. This can pose problems for the holding company if it wishes to complete a share sale and the minority interests reject it.
Legal Framework
The primary legislation governing minority shareholder rights in Australia is the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act). Companies must be well-versed in the following key provisions when dealing with minority interests and their internal corporate governance:
- Grounds for Court Orders (Section 232): Companies must ensure their affairs are not conducted in a manner oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to minority shareholders. This includes fair treatment in decision-making, profit distribution, and access to information;
- Derivative Actions (Sections 236-242): Companies should be aware that minority shareholders can, with court permission, bring legal action on behalf of the company against directors or other parties for wrongs done to the company;
- Inspection of Books (Sections 247A-247C): Companies must be prepared for court-ordered inspections of company books and records by shareholders, highlighting the importance of maintaining accurate and transparent records;
- General Meetings (Sections 249D-249F): Companies must facilitate general meetings called by shareholders holding at least 5% of votes, ensuring that minority voices can be heard; and
- Compulsory Acquisition Protections (Part 6A.2): In takeover situations, companies must adhere to strict rules protecting minority shareholders, including fair value assessments, relevant thresholds and the court’s powers.
Financial Considerations
Additionally, companies must navigate the financial landscape to maintain positive and beneficial relationships with their shareholders and ensure the company’s smooth operation.
Dividend Policies
Companies should establish and communicate a clear, fair dividend policy that balances reinvestment needs with shareholder returns. The policy must comply with the Act’s solvency requirements and be reasonable to all shareholders.
Related Party Transactions
Companies, especially those listed on the ASX, must carefully manage and disclose related party transactions. Compliance with ASX Listing Rules and the Act is crucial, often requiring shareholder approval for significant transactions. If these requirements are not followed, it can pose severe consequences for the company and potentially its directors.
Financial Reporting
Comprehensive and transparent financial reporting is essential. Companies must adhere to Australian Accounting Standards and the Act’s disclosure requirements, ensuring minority shareholders can accurately assess company performance.
Tax Implications
To create a tax consolidated group, the holding company must wholly own the subsidiaries. The income tax system treats consolidated groups as one entity for tax purposes. The implication of owning a subsidiary with minority interests means that the parent company cannot become a tax consolidated group with its subsidiaries. Each company in the group will be taxed as if each entity is separate. This applies even to each of the group entities. Each member must separately account for all the transactions, debt, and equity interests between them.
Capital Raising
When raising capital, companies must structure offerings to avoid unfairly diluting minority shareholdings. This involves careful consideration of pre-emptive rights and providing transparency during the capital raising process.
Valuation
In situations such as compulsory acquisitions or share buy-backs, companies must ensure fair valuation of minority interests. This often involves engaging independent external experts for reports and advice.
Managing the Minority Interests
The best strategies that companies should consider implementing to manage minority interests and mitigate the risks associated with minority interests are as follows:
- implementing strong corporate governance practices, including independent directors and audit committees, can help ensure fair treatment of all shareholders;
- regular, clear communication with all shareholders, including detailed annual reports and timely market updates, can build trust and reduce miscommunication that can lead to disputes;
- proactively engaging with minority shareholders, seeking their input on major decisions, and addressing their concerns can prevent conflicts and foster a positive relationship;
- considering mechanisms for minority shareholder representation on the board or advisory committees can help ensure diverse perspectives are considered in decision-making;
- establishing clear dispute resolution procedures can provide efficient means of addressing shareholder conflicts; and
- ensuring corporate actions such as mergers, acquisitions, or restructurings purposefully consider and protect minority interests, potentially offering tag-along rights or other protections.
Key Takeaways
Effective management of minority interests is crucial for Australian companies in terms of legal compliance and building a strong, sustainable corporate structure. By prioritising fair treatment, transparent communication, and strong governance practices, companies can best manage minority interests and develop their relationship with the shareholders. Regular review of policies and practices and ongoing engagement with all shareholders will be key to navigating the legal and financial considerations associated with minority interests.
If you have any questions regarding minority interests, our experienced business lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 1300 544 755 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does a minority interest affect financial reporting and taxation?
A parent company that does not fully own its subsidiary cannot form a tax consolidated group with it. This means each company must file separate tax returns, leading to additional compliance costs. Transparent financial reporting is also crucial to ensure minority shareholders can access accurate company performance data.
How can companies manage minority interests effectively?
To manage minority interests, companies should:
- implement strong corporate governance practices;
- maintain clear and regular communication with all shareholders;
- provide fair valuation in share buy-backs and acquisitions;
- offer mechanisms for minority representation in decision-making; and
- establish clear dispute resolution processes.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
